What Your Left Hand Should (and Shouldn't) Do in Piano Accompaniment

In piano accompaniment, play full triads in the left hand only around middle C, switch to fifths (root–fifth–octave) or spread 1–5–10 voicings lower down, and use bare octaves or single roots in the very lowest register, because closely spaced low notes sound muddy.

Video lesson by Jason Zac · Intermediate · 23 min

Can't see the video? Watch it on YouTube.

This lesson from Jason Zac at Nathaniel School of Music builds left-hand awareness: knowing what to play in each register of the piano. It uses a simple, epic-sounding melody in E minor over four chords, and works for beginners learning to play a melody with harmony as well as more advanced players who are comfortable with the sustain pedal.

The registers of the piano

A register is simply a pitch range. For the left hand, think of three zones: around middle C, below middle C and really low. Each zone suits a different kind of left-hand part, and the rule comes from physics: in the low register the frequencies of chord notes sit too close together, so a full triad turns muddy. It is like trying to tell apart two very dark colours.

The key and the chords

The melody is in E natural minor: E F# G A B C D E, the relative minor of G major (one sharp). The chords are:

• Em – E G B
• D – D F# A (the major chord on the seventh degree, often called bVII)
• C – C E G, or Cmaj7 by adding B
• Bm – B D F#, or Bm7 – B D F# A

Start by playing the whole melody over just an E minor chord, then add the four chords.

Step 1: Block triads around middle C

Around middle C it is fine to play the full triad, such as E G B. Do not take that same close triad down low; it may be a beautiful chord, but it sounds unpleasant in the bass. Add dynamics so some notes stand out, and imagine a drummer playing along to keep the rhythm alive.

Step 2: Move the chord into the right hand

As the left hand goes lower, it can no longer carry the full chord, so the right hand takes over. Add other chord notes beneath the melody and invert the chord so the melody stays on top. This works because most conventional melodies stress the root, third or fifth of the chord. You can play these right-hand chords as blocks or arpeggiate them, holding the sustain pedal.

Step 3: Fifth chords lower down

Below middle C, drop the third and play a fifth chord: root, fifth and octave, for example E B E for E minor. Play it in any rhythm you like. Meanwhile, slightly thicken the right hand with the harmony, since it now supplies the third.

Step 4: Spread voicing (open 10ths)

If you want the third back in the left hand, use a spread voicing: 1, 5, 10. The 10th is the third an octave higher, so E minor becomes E, B and the G above. This stretch is hard to hold in one hand, so arpeggiate it.

Step 5: Octaves and roots very low

For the most epic sound, drop the chords and play just the roots as octaves or single notes at the very bottom of the piano, down to the lowest E. Octaves sound huge low down, but played too high they intrude on the melody. To get the best of both worlds, play the low root, then jump up and play the triad around middle C, slightly delayed. The sustain pedal is essential here, as your hand cannot make that jump smoothly without it.

A note on keyboards

A 61-key keyboard is the bare minimum. On one, use the transpose button (minus 12) or octave minus one to shift everything down an octave so you can reach the low register.

How to practise

1. Learn the melody alone, then over E minor only.
2. Play it with block triads around middle C.
3. Switch to fifths lower, then spread 1–5–10 voicings.
4. Finish with low octaves plus a delayed triad near middle C, using the pedal.
5. Apply the same register rules to songs and covers you are learning.

Questions about this lesson

Why do left-hand chords sound muddy low on the piano?

In the low register the frequencies of the chord notes are too close together for the ear to separate clearly. Use fifths or octaves there instead of full triads.

What is a 1-5-10 spread voicing?

It is a left-hand voicing of root, fifth and the tenth, which is the third an octave higher. For E minor that is E, B and the G above, usually played as an arpeggio because it is a wide stretch.

Where should I play octaves in the left hand?

Octaves sound biggest in the lower region of the keyboard. Played too high, they intrude on the melody and lose their heavy, epic quality.

Can I do this on a 61-key keyboard?

Yes. 61 keys is the minimum; use the transpose button set to minus 12 or the octave down function so you can reach the low notes.

Practise it

• Voicing RoomA hands-on lesson room for piano chord voicings.
• Pop LessonsPractice companions for Jason Zac’s pop piano lessons: octave fillers, chord changes and inversions in every key.
• Piano classes at Nathaniel School of MusicLive online or in Bangalore, with a teacher.
• All free music apps40 practice tools for harmony, rhythm, ear training and more.

Related lessons

• The 5 Pillars of Piano Accompaniment for Any GenreJason Zac's five pillars of piano accompaniment are ballad chords with a chosen time feel, arpeggio patterns, a low-high marching groove, the tresillo dance rhythm, and copying the drummer's kick, snare and hi-hat, all built by first deciding how the beat is divided.
• How to Make Left-Hand Piano Chords Sound HugeTo make left-hand piano chords sound huge without getting muddy, use a spread voicing: play the root, then the fifth, then the third an octave higher (a tenth), so F major becomes F C A and F minor becomes F C Ab.
• Piano Hand Independence Workout Using the Bossa Clave (Dance Groove)To build piano hand independence for dance music, play the bossa (pop) clave, a one-bar sixteenth-note rhythm, in one hand while the other keeps a steady four-beat pulse over a Bm–D–F#m–E progression, then swap the roles of the hands.
• The Easiest Way to Make Piano Chords More Complex (Spread Voicing)To make piano chords more complex, play the triad as a left-hand spread voicing (root, fifth, then the third an octave higher as a tenth), keep the root and tenth fixed, and change only the middle note to create sixth, seventh and augmented chords.